Why didn't Dumbledore think of using a basilisk fang to destroy the horcruxes? In the film adaptation of Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, the Basilisk is shown to hear Harry Potter, something that Tom Riddles memory also points out. Basilisks in Britain for at least four hundred years. For example, Ginny poured her fears and desires into the diary, thus it was easy for Tom to possess her. Everything else he left to Harry, making an already difficult mission even more difficult. Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. He knows that the diary is what brought Riddle back and Riddle isn't quite fully formed yet. Yes, in the 2nd book when harry's in the Chamber of secrets, But he didn't know the whole truth. When J.K. Rowling explains why being poisoned with basilisk venom didn't kill the soul piece in Harry, she explains that Harry was mended before he was destroyed, and that phoenix tears have to be administered immediately or the basilisk venom makes the object irreparable, presumably even by phoenix tears. Or he did and his note with his big list of "how to destroy Horcruxes" failed to reach Harry in the chaos that was Voldemort overthrowing the Ministry. "From all that I've read, what Harry did to Riddle's diary was one of the few really foolproof ways of destroying a Horcrux.". How did Harry know the Basilisk fang would destroy the diary? like the next man. desk, he looked as old and weary as Harry had ever seen him. Why didn't Dumbledore give Harry more of a head-start by telling him about the Basilisk fangs? complete answer When Harry Potter entered the Chamber of Secrets and met a magical manifestation of a teenage Tom Riddle, Tom Riddle seemed to know about Harry already. Riddle is the Heir of Slytherin. After all, convinced as he is that his plans are infallible, what does it matter if there are some risks? Soon enough, Harry was communicating with Tom Riddle, who showed him a memory within the diary, in which Riddle confronted Rubeus Hagrid about the keeping of a dangerous pet. Dumbledore knew basilisk fangs would be supremely useful to Harry. [1], Later, Ginny, having seen the diary amongst Harry's books, stole the diary from among Harry's room in the Gryffindor Boys' Dormitory. Fawkes drops the diary in Harry's lap and Harry grabs the nearest available weapon (the fang) and destroys the diary. Ginny poured her soul into the diary, that's why Memory-Tom gained the Corpeal form when Harry entered the Chamber. on harrypotter.fandom.com, View . he also gave harry all he needed by telling him to find the sword in his will. I can easily see Dumbledore going over the pieces in his head and assuming that Harry, or at least Hermione, would just 'get it' immediately: (Dumbledore thinking to himself): Harry (a) knows the diary was a Horcrux; (b) destroyed the diary with Basilisk venom straight from the fang. Ginny Weasley tried to flush it down the toilet, but it came back perfect as new. word would not rise to his lips, Aberforth seemed to know what he was Riddle has Harry's wand and the sword is stuck in the basilisk. As this diary contained Riddle's soul, it also housed his magical powers. That's easy to do and doesn't necessarily equate to arrogance (it's something I've had to learn the hard way after being called out on it though in my case it wasn't about anyone but myself). As a Horcrux, the diary allowed a writer to communicate with the memory of the sixteen-year-old Tom Riddle, merely through writing on the journal's blank pages. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? Ron did so by imitating Harry, but Dumbledore did not speak Parseltongue. Hence that portion of soul would also not have died. @DavidS He wouldn't need to tell McGonagall the purpose of the items. Based from Slughorn's information, Riddle became positive on the possibility of creating more than one Horcrux, and became confident of using the diary as a weapon instead of the intended safeguard. The only thing Dumbledore ever did to defeat Voldemort was to destroy the ring horcrux. I come to think of only one simple available answer that the basilisk might have only two fangs like other snakes used for piercing venom one was used by Harry in the chamber of secrets itself and the other by ron and hermione in the end. What countries have only 2 syllable in their name? and feelings you have been enjoying. The girl that showed her breast on Joe Dirt? Hence why Snape was trying to teach Harry to block his mind from the connection. Couldn't he just ask Harry to open . Why does the USA not have a constitutional court? Harry could have used the Basilisk to destroy Tom Riddle's diary, though he might have still had to kill the creature in order to avoid more danger and in case Voldemort made a full return, otherwise, the Dark Lord could have easily returned for the Basilisk and use it to kill a lot of people, mostly at Hogwarts. What's the \synctex primitive? And Dumbledores portrait suggests otherwise that he wanted Harry to survive: indeed thats exactly what he hoped for. Why did the Basilisk fang not destroy the Horcrux in Harry? Salazar Slytherins basilisk was born in the chamber, as revealed by Aragog. Thanks for contributing an answer to Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange! The power of something that answers you back, and at the time that I wrote that I'd never been in an Internet chat room. Also, he didn't anticipate the Death Eaters being able to get access to Hogworts, so he probably thought he had more time to get his affairs in order. Is there any reason on passenger airliners not to have a physical lock between throttles? He had already explained to Harry what he knew about Voldemort's Horcruxes. Why did Harry resent Dumbledore at the beginning of Deathly Hallows? For most of Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, it does not feel that different from those that came before. When You Breathe In Your Diaphragm Does What. To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. One explanation would be that Dumbledore is stupid, but in general he is not described as stupid. Avada Kedavra kills. One other point: Dumbledore was admittedly brilliant. He knows that the diary is what brought Riddle back and Riddle isn't quite fully formed yet. And why didn't he put the fangs, the sword, the Beedle book, the Deluminator and the snitch in a box for McGonagall to give away after he died? For the fear of sounding like every other Potterhead on this site, this is the problem with watching the movies without reading the books. . In reality, the matter was more complicated, as Dumbledore would reveal to Harry in Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince that the diary was just one of seven Horcruxes. He probably at first suspected Harry would have to die without any way around it but he was glad when Voldemort took Harrys blood though he didnt tell poor Severus. So it must be obvious that Basilisk venom kills Horcruxes. What is the difference between Hello Kitty and Sanrio? Even if he was to die soon he would have handled things differently although we don't know how differently it's most likely it would be. Why didn't Dumbledore leave Harry a big pile of basilisk fangs? asked Harry. Why can Horcruxes only be destroyed by basilisk venom? This healed him instantly, saving his life. details of his plans hidden, even from those closest to him. In Hagrids third year, he was framed by Tom Riddle for the crime of opening the Chamber of Secrets and using his pet Acromantula to attack several Muggle-born students and eventually killing one of them. Welcome to the video! @TheDarkLord - Clearly he did not feel it was necessary to give Harry everything early. Why didn't anyone else suspect the Horcruxes' existence? complete answer on wizardingworld.com, View Alternatively, Dumbledore thought that Harry getting his hands on the Sword of Gryffindor again was a much more reliable way to get ahold of a Horcrux-destroying weapon than than going back down into the Chamber of Secrets and risking his life extracting basilisk fangs that could kill him if he got nicked. The closer a writer became to the memory of Tom Riddle emotionally, the more power the diary would acquire over him or her. If Dumbledore knew so much about horcruxes, why would he have fatally afflicted himself trying to destroy one? This act was an endeavour to create a physical body for the sixteen-year-old Soul of Tom Riddle. [2] Riddle would later use this murder to infuse the journal with a piece of his soul, and transformed it into his first Horcrux.[3]. Just so that when Dumbledore thought it would be the time to die, Harry would walk willingly to his death without questions. Being right almost all the time if not always is really toxic to the mind! In secret, Malfoy kept the diary before he slipped it, unnoticed, into Ginny Weasley's cauldron of school supplies at Flourish and Blotts in 1992.[7]. said Harry. After being healed, Harry took the fang and stabbed Riddle's diary, destroying that Horcrux beyond magical repair. [8] She soon learned how to use the diary to communicate with Tom Riddle, though she was unaware that he was Lord Voldemort, or if he was even real. Dumbledore might have thought that if Harry made the connection of the venom destroying Horcruxes he would be able to easily acesss the Chamber again because he had already done so. Dumbledore might have directly told Harry about it if he had lived more. Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. I'd assumed he did not trust McGonagall, or anyone else (a wise attitude in a world with Veritaserum, Legilimancy and the Imperius curse). What does a judge look for in a character letter? Because Harry had stabbed the Basilisk with the sword, it was imbued with Basilisk venom and was therefore able to destroy Horcruxes and poison opponents that it cuts through as well. However, the diary was also likely a different case given that it also was intended as a weapon and looked innocent enough to lure its victims to write in it. Job done. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. Thats a testament to Dumbledores brilliance and power. Even though he knew that he was dying, Dumbledore obviously took care to tailor his will to helping Harry. After Myrtle's death, Albus Dumbledore, then Professor of Transfiguration, began suspecting Riddle. As Dumbledore himself says: Naturally I do, but as I have already proven to you, I make mistakes To destroy a Horcrux in a living host, the host must be killed. It is why Neville had to kill Nagini rather than just stab her with the sword. . She would probably say that it makes the mission and therefor the book more exciting, but if most troubles come from someone supposedly on Harry's side, then the question is whether Dumbledore is really on Harry's side. Beside the basilisk fang. We only ever see the one in the Chamber of Secrets. Why did the basilisk fang not destroy Harry's Horcrux. Slytherins Basilisk slithering through the Chamber of Secrets In 1943, the Chamber of Secrets was opened by a Slytherin Fifth year, named Tom Riddle, who was able to control the Basilisk through his status as the Heir of Slytherin. The answer is simple: He didn't actually die . When the Weasleys and Harry left to King's Cross Station, Ginny accidentally left the diary behind at the Burrow. On the evening of 29 May, 1993, Harry returned to the girls' lavatory and successfully discovered and opened the Chamber of Secrets. Similarly, Albus Dumbledore managed to control the Elder Wand without killing its previous master who, in fact, outlived him. As for the rest, it's a guess about Dumbledore's motivation, although you are right, Lily and the stone doesn't belong here. And he himself used the sword because it was handy right in his office. As the answer to this question ponders, Dumbledore seems to have left a lot of information out when giving Harry, Ron and Hermione their Horcrux assignment. He did not gave the second basilisk to Harry because it would need opening the chamber of secrets and one basilisk could destroy one horcrux only but the sword could be used as many times. If I say it myself, Harry, I've always been able to charm the people I needed.Tom Riddle's manipulation of Ginny Weasley, Some time during the First Wizarding War, Lord Voldemort entrusted the diary to Death Eater, Lucius Malfoy. Join me as we look at the Tom Riddle Diary and Basilisk Fang! Voldemort has finally realized the dangerous access to his thoughts The diary. At which point entering it becomes extremely difficult for Harry since he is a wanted man! How to smoothen the round border of a created buffer to make it look more natural? It only takes a minute to sign up. It was the first Horcrux he ever made and was used as a weapon. Then, without thinking, without considering, as though he had meant to do it all. The Basilisk attacked several members of the Hogwarts community, including Mrs Norris, Colin Creevey, Justin Finch-Fletchley, Nearly-Headless Nick, Hermione Granger, and Penelope Clearwater. He later made the ring into his second Horcrux. Just before they got to the motorway, she remembered the diary and demanded to be allowed to go back and get it. Despite the known risks of using the diary as a weapon instead of a safeguard, Voldemort was nevertheless furious to learn of its destruction,[16] due to Lucius implementing the plan without Voldemort's say-so in order to dispose of the diary for his own benefit while also attempting to destroy the Weasley family and Dumbledore's reputation, as well as getting rid of an incriminating Dark Arts artefact (the Ministry was conducting a search at the time); this was one of the many reasons that he lost trust in the Malfoy family and why Lucius was punished and demoted. This Horcrux, of course, was destroyed by Harry with the basilisk fang during that final confrontation with Riddle. Who is the actress in the otezla commercial? left in me hed have it too. This is in line with Dumbledore doing nothing to prepare Harry for fighting Voldemort. Can a prospective pilot be negated their certification because of too big/small hands? Why Didn't Dumbledore Take the Sword of Gryffindor With Him to the Sea Cave (Locket Horcrux)? Why Wasn't the Resurrection Stone Destroyed Along With the Ring Horcrux? The quote of his actually directly contradicts that though doesn't it? @TheLethalCarrot It is my conclusion from reading the books that JKR wanted Harry to be miserable, I don't think that there are quotes to this effect in the books. Voldemort wanted to split his soul in seven parts, seven considered magical number in wizarding world. he couldn't even find it when he looked, according to Binns. [14] Harry followed the voices through the Hogwarts corridors until he came upon the second floor girls' lavatory. Continue Learning about General Arts & Entertainment. With the Hallows, Dumbledore later says that he had intended to be cryptic in an attempt to let Hermione's natural caution prevent Harry from going too power-hungry. Voldemort and Dumbledore do seem to share a love of elaborate plans, which don't always work in their favour. The Basilisk almost killed Harry with its poisonous fangs, but Fawkes saved him with his magical tears. In the film adaptation, Harry destroyed the diary with the fang. Dumbledore knew about Horcruxes, but even then he didn't have a complete knowledge and had to get memories from Slughorn in the sixth book not long before his death in order to get the whole story. Eventually one of the Muggle-borns, a Ravenclaw girl named Myrtle Warren, was killed by the Basilisk. Actually she wanted Harry to be as miserable as possible, and making his mission unnecessarily difficult is part of that. Fawkes blinds the basilisk. Why is Singapore currently considered to be a dictatorial regime and a multi-party democracy by different publications? Hoping to revive his dead family members (particularly his sister Ariana Dumbledore), he disregarded the rings status as a Horcrux and put it on. Voldemort himself decided that he did not want this name, however. How many lanes are there in standard athletic track? If Harry knew about the Horcruxes and how to destroy them before he could shield his mind there was a great possibility that Voldemort would find out and be able to protect his greatest assets. Considering Draco Malfoy's reaction to finding the diary with Harry, Lucius apparently never showed the diary to his son. How do I know if I'm feeding my betta enough? Answer (1 of 2): In the Harry Potter universe, phoenixes are immortal creatures. Site design / logo 2022 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. Answer (1 of 12): He didn't. > Then, in a rush of wings, Fawkes had soared back overhead and something fell into Harry's lap the diary. This ties in somewhat with his arrogance. complete answer on harry-potter-compendium.fandom.com, View It appears that he is now I, on the other hand, thought otherwise, said Dumbledore. Dumbledore knew that this would be a flawed way of passing things on. In the seventh book/eighth movie, the Diadem of Rowena Ravenclaw is destroyed. And so that was always a very scary image to me, in the book, and I thought it worked very well in the film. Looking at the events from an in-story point of view, most of Harry's troubles (as well as most of his suffering) are caused by Dumbledore, whether directly or indirectly. He knows that the diary is what brought Riddle back and Riddle isn't quite fully formed yet. Of course, though perhaps Dumbledore shouldn't be judged too harshly, he should indeed be judged negatively on this score. Why did Ginny open the Chamber of Secrets? Let's consider the following points. "Why didn't I ask him? proud about these types of things, that is. Her emotional vulnerability allowed the fragment of Voldemort's soul within the diary to gain partial control of her mind. By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. Plus, what Valorum said. Knowing how to destroy Horcruxes is clearly an integral part of any mission to destroy Horcruxes! The diary used its dark magical influence to bewitch and force Ginny to re-open the Chamber of Secrets, but it was destroyed by Harry Potter in 1993 with a Basilisk's Fang. Where is it documented? Riddle has Harry's wand and the sword is stuck in the basilisk. It seems like actual knowledge of them was fairly scant, so I doubt he'd have a ready "ACME HORCRUX DESTRUCTION KIT" at the ready to pass on. Thus, it would be quite difficult for Dumbledore to have left a great pile of fangs as he would be unable to control a live Basilisk as is not a parselmouth, and dead Basilisks are incredibly rare. He also didnt expect to die that night so we cannot judge him wholly on what he did or didnt do and tell Harry. He said my blood would make him stronger than if hed used someone Dumbledore just left the Hogwarts library books lying around in his office and made no attempt to bequeath them to Harry. Seems suspicious. He trusted Snape with the biggest secret of all, remember! imagined it, for when Dumbledore had returned to his seat behind the harry-potter. How did Salazar Slytherin get a basilisk? There was a dead Basilisk decaying in the Chamber of Secrets, though. Dumbledore admits he knew that Harry would have ten dark years even before he placed him with the Dursleys. He's clearly not proud about his mistakes in his youth but that's why he did everything he could to make amends in the way he was able to. In LEGO Harry Potter: Years 5-7, Harry uses Sectumsempra on Malfoy only to find out the spell has, apparently, painlessly sliced him in half. I think you've earned the points. As the venom (from the fang) destroyed Riddle's book, why didn't it destroy first the Last Horcrux, within Harry? 3/8 Goblet of Fire. Harry destroyed it using the Basilisk's fang in 1993 when he encountered Voldemort's soul in the Chambers of Secrets during the second movie. I mean close emotionally. @TheDarkLord Of course, if he'd known the whole truth, it wouldn't have been very difficult for him at all: he would have known that really he had the support of the new Headmaster (and of course McGonagall and the others as well) who could have sneaked him in no problem. Interestingly, the book could be compared to, In a deleted scene from the film adaptation of. Why did Dumbledore never ask Harry how to destroy a horcrux? This implied to Harry that Hagrid had opened the Chamber of Secrets, but Riddle was merely using Hagrid's pet Acromantula, Aragog, as a scapegoat so Hogwarts would not be closed down, and had in fact been using a monster that was infinitely more dangerous himself, showing that his actions (though done to eliminate suspicion) were also shallow hypocrisy. Yet, Dumbledore did not hear the basilisk during the events of Chamber of Secrets. anybody else, and there have been no recorded sightings of Dumbledore clearly knew in Goblet of Fire that Voldemort's taking Harry's blood could be a great benefit, yet did not tell Harry until he was half-dead. Dumbledore must've known that Hogwarts was at risk of falling into Voldemort's hands after his death. Riddle has Harry's wand and the sword is stuck in the basilisk. And one failing brilliant people sometimes have is that they forget other people aren't quite as sharp as they are. How did Harry know the Basilisk fang would destroy the diary? What will happen if utensils used for fermentation and pickling are made of aluminum instead of stainless steel or glass? It shared this attribute with a fellow Horcrux of Voldemort. I think some credit must be given to the recognition that Dumbledore didn't expect to be killed that night in the tower. Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. That made his face more serpentine and his nose changed into two snakelike slits. TypeError: unsupported operand type(s) for *: 'IntVar' and 'float'. Yes, I know Fawkes quite quickly healed the bite wound with his phoenix tears, but when Harry used the basilisk fang to destroy Tom Riddle's diary the destruction of that Horcrux was immediate. 'After all, convinced as he is that his plans are infallible, what does it matter if there are some risks?' Ive got a job. ", In the book, Harry Potter only destroyed the diary with the Basilisk fang after he was healed by Fawkes. elses, Harry told Dumbledore. Why not use another method to give Harry and co what they needed earlier? That can be the cursed fire Goyle (I think it was Goyle) used in the room of requirement, the killing curse or Basilisk venom. In the United States, must state courts follow rulings by federal courts of appeals? She also strangled the school roosters to protect the Basilisk. Harry didn't know how to destroy Horcruxes. This is not merely some post hoc justification created for the final book, either: He did not tell Harry about the magical protection his mother had placed on him until Harry had experienced firsthand. It was only sheer, dumb luck/quick thinking on Hermione's part that meant that the trio knew the theory of Horcrux-destruction. - I'll just leave Harry the Sword in my Will! While at Hogwarts, Tom openly wore the ring. These individuals were not murdered by the Basilisk, but Petrified, due to them never seeing the Basilisk directly through a series of fortunate events, ranging from seeing a reflection to seeing it through a camera to the viewer being dead already. It is stabbed with a basilisk fang and then kicked into a Fiendfyre. Just typing your deepest thoughts into the ether and getting answers back, and you don't know who is answering you. Voldemort does not have a nose because his physical appearance changed due to him delving deeper and deeper into the dark magic. Ginny wrote all of her deepest feelings and secrets in the diary, including her feelings of infatuation toward Harry Potter. He probably simply thought he had more time to explain, to plot, etc. He could even cause the diary writer to speak it while possessing them, which was instrumental in reopening the Chamber of Secrets. The basilisk is a legendary gigantic snake. How did Harry know the Basilisk fang would destroy the diary? As his The ability to speak Parseltongue is usually inborn; a wizard is born being able to speak Parseltongue, and those who are not born with the ability cannot normally learn the language (although, according to the author, Dumbledore may have learned to understand it, and in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Ron learnt . @Adamant But that's not giving him the chance to defend himself. My diary. So why wasn't the Horcrux residing in Harry's head destroyed when he was bitten by the Basilisk? plot-explanation. [15] She feared that Riddle would tell Harry about her feelings toward him, and shortly thereafter went missing. Once the diary had partial control of her he forced her to re-open the Chamber of Secrets. Adding the Slytherins Locket to the destroyed list and leaving Harry out (since it was unknown to them) , Ron said 3 to go, which were Hufflepuffs cup, Ravenclaws Diadem and Nagini. So, it was an understood thing for Dumbledore that Harry and co. could easily infer how to destroy a Horcrux and they could also obtain Basilisk fangs. complete answer Nothing suspicious in his comments or answers that I have seen. Dumbledore knew that, if Harry didn't get hold of the sword, basilisk fangs remained the main key tool Harry needed for Horcrux-destruction. Where does the idea of selling dragon parts come from? [1][2] The diary could transport the reader into a realm of memories, much like the Pensieve. He could not hide it from himself: Ron had been right. Nor can they be killed by any means, as we can see when Fawkes swallows the Killing Curse meant for Harry . Home | About | Contact | Copyright | Privacy | Cookie Policy | Terms & Conditions | Sitemap. This enacted the rings deadly curse, and it began to quickly spread through Dumbledores body, starting with the hand on which he had put the ring. Perhaps but he had his reasons. It was here that he discovered the water-logged diary, which Ginny had discarded when she suspected that it was she who had petrified the Muggle-borns and finally realised that the diary was the cause. At the start of their quest they had no practical means of destroying them. And his mum didnt at all imply that. Parselmouths, they are as dangerous to most Dark wizards as to deafeat the basilisk who lives in the chamber of secrets. triumph in Dumbledores eyes. This diary was used as a weapon, so as to unleash the Basilisk once again in Hogwarts, rather than keeping the portion of the soul safe, which was what Horcruxes were meant for. complete answer on harrypotter.fandom.com. After the diary was destroyed, Fawkes mended Harry's arm with his tears. Trying to give it to Harry gave him a hint but this is as close as Harry gets to finding out how to destroy Horcruxes. Remember that Riddle was the best student Hogwarts had ever seen and thats said by another brilliant student - Dumbledore himself! Why Dumbledore didn't tell Harry how to destroy horcruxes? Harry slayed the Basilisk with the assistance of Dumbledore's phoenix, Fawkes and the Sword of Gryffindor, which appeared from the Sorting Hat. Not only does it destroy the one in Tom Riddle's diary, but Ron and Hermione also use one of the fangs to destroy Helga Hufflepuff's cup. She was forced to paint a threat against her life on the walls of a hallway and sealed herself inside the Chamber. The sword and the supposed 2nd Basilisk are not what's being asked about here. [13], Hermione eventually deduced that the monster had to be a Basilisk, due to Harry's ability to hear it and the nature of the attacks, but she was petrified before she could inform Harry or Ron, though she managed to leave them a relatively straightforward clue, a clipping from a Magizoology book Most Macabre Monstrosities.[12]. In 1996, Albus Dumbledore retrieved the ring, eventually destroying it with Godric Gryffindors Sword. Maybe he wanted an exciting game to watch from his "next adventure". J. K. Rowling has also stated: "Now, the diary to me is a very scary object, a really, really frightening object. In the following years, Riddle also questioned Potions Master, Horace Slughorn about the properties of a Horcrux and how one might create multiple ones. he was a natural.. And even if Voldemort was defeated by an unlikely sequence of events, many people died in the war, and many Muggleborns were killed during the year Voldemort controlled the ministry. The fact it had never been done makes me think she did what every loving mother would do: lay down their life for their child. [1] The diary was also able to siphon the life force from a reader and transfer it to Riddle's stored memory. This manipulative little book, the temptation particularly for a young girl to pour out her heart to a diary, which is never something I was prone to, but my sister was. However, Malfoy still possessed the diary and, in 1992, he planted it on Ginny Weasley, hoping to kill three birds with one stone by sabotaging Ginny's father, purge the school of Muggle-borns, and eliminate an incriminating Dark artefact.[4]. Answer (1 of 10): Aw jeez. Your first two paragraphs seem to answer the question but are entirely unsourced, could you. How much should I spend monthly on a car? So it must be obvious that the Sword of Gryffindor can now destroy Horcruxes! Or he did and most of the options weren't very doable for someone like Harry, given that the most talked about alternative to basilisk venom is Fiendfyre, which is extremely dangerous to use. Which Horcrux did Harry destroy? But he did expect to be killed very soon, right? Nagini is one of many snakes featured in the series. Welcome to SFF! While he is indeed one of the most brilliant wizards alive, his high opinion of himself can lead him to make grievous errors, since he assumes that any plan he makes will turn out flawlessly. There are still dangerous situations . Dumbledore had left him with virtually nothing. Would the Basilisk have listened to Harry? Required fields are marked *. Otoh Voldemort suggesting this is suicidal.. Influenced by Riddle's charisma and believing his own wisdom was being admired, Slughorn told Riddle what little he knew on the subject, though he expressed the worry that Riddle was intending to create Horcruxes rather than simply discuss them. This was only achievable as basilisk venom was an extremely destructive substance capable of destroying Horcruxes. This included his ability to speak Parseltongue. most men, my mistakes tend to be correspondingly huger.. The stuff is obscenely poisonous, to the point where the only antidote is Phoenix tears. @Jeutnarg On the contrary; The Dark Lord is a great bloke. See what we know: Dumbledore had already told Harry that the Tom Riddle's Diary was a Horcrux which was already destroyed. For a fleeting instant, Harry thought he saw a gleam of something like Would it be possible, given current technology, ten years, and an infinite amount of money, to construct a 7,000 foot (2200 meter) aircraft carrier? Because of how careless this Horcrux was treated (after all, its purpose was to keep its owner immortal), Dumbledore theorised that Riddle had created more Horcruxes, something that had never been done before.[3]. Ginny was forced not only to paint terrifying threats in the school corridors using blood,[9] but she released the Basilisk within the Chamber as well. Horcruxes are not common knowledge in the Wizarding World, and knowledge of how to destroy them is even rarer. For a split second, both Harry and Riddle, wand still raised, stared at it. [10] She did all this while in a sort of trance, never knowing what she had done. She did it because she was being used by Riddle, who opened the Chamber 50 years prior. What did Ginny write in Tom Riddles diary? Warner Brothers Pictures. After much effort, he destroyed it in 1996 in his office, using Godric Griffindor's sword. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. brother says, I cant leave, said Harry. He said the protection my my mother In addition, Dumbledore would have been unable to even leave the one fang in the Chamber of Secrets, as Dumbledore is not a parselmouth and would be unable to open it. So just because he suggested opening the chamber..well so did Ron. Harry heard strange voices in the walls of Hogwarts, which exhorted the urge to kill. on scifi.stackexchange.com, View The answer is simple: View And although James was a bullying git he also sacrificed himself although he was never given a choice by Voldemort. Did Dumbledore know Harry could hear the Basilisk? What Dumbledore does is preparing Harry to get killed by Voldemort. Vote on future topics for SFF topic challenges! Your point about the fangs being potentially dangerous is an interesting one, though. Hogwarts was again under threat of being closed down. In Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2, Voldemort may have used this spell to slit Snapes throat before having Nagini finish him off. Hence, he created his own body. "Oh, well, lucky we've got a large supply of Basilisk fangs, then," said Ron. As it turns out, Fawkes not only saved Harry but also the part of Voldemort's soul living in him. [3], I was patient. Thats exactly what Dumbledore did. Crossword Clue. How many transistors at minimum do you need to build a general-purpose computer? They do not die of old age as evidenced by the time when Fawkes is reborn as a baby chick from its own ashes. Its got to be me, Dumbledore explained it all Oh, did he Then, without thinking, without considering, as though he had meant to do it all along, Harry seized the basilisk fang on the floor next to him and plunged it straight into the heart of the book. He had lots of things going on in his life (including a curse which was going to kill him within a year) and such understood thing was low priority to him. He was considered a genius, he knew there was a dead basilisk in the chamber of secrets at Hogwarts and that Harry destroyed Tom Riddle's diary with its fang but instead of doing it the simple way, he kept thinking of other ways. Harry Potter Wiki is a FANDOM Movies Community. (Basilisks can live for hundreds of years, so there probably aren't too many dead ones anyways.). Having him there destroyed any sense of self worth that Harry would have had. The basilisk's poison was strong enough to destroy a horcrux, making fans wonder why the one in Harry didn't die when he was bitten by the giant serpent. The majority of Dumbledore's items were left to Hogwarts. Browse other questions tagged, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site, Learn more about Stack Overflow the company. [1][2] When Harry's ink bottles shattered and drenched all of his other textbooks, the diary alone remained dry and unmarked.[1]. However, due to the circumstances regarding the diary, it may not have been, especially if the teachers regarded it as worthless, not aware that it was a Horcrux. He knew that Hermione would try to see if he had any books on Horcruxes. You're in trouble if you get too fond of or dependent on the Horcrux.A Horcrux's ability to influence a person. He knows he's not infallible but yes he does tend to let his mostly good guesses get to his head. Dumbledore had no reason not to tell Harry. He knows that the diary is what brought Riddle back and Riddle isn't quite fully formed yet. What dissolves human hair in a washing machine? Of course, the Ministry won't give it to him, but the fact that I tried will be a dead giveaway! They initially suspected Draco Malfoy, who was openly prejudiced against Muggle-borns, but after using Polyjuice Potion to spy on him, they discovered that, other than him knowing that the Chamber of Secrets had previously been opened fifty years ago, he knew as little about the attacks as they did. complete answer on scifi.stackexchange.com, View 25 results for "harry . This is why, in Chamber of Secrets Harry stabbed Tom Riddles diary with a basilisk fang and in Deathly Hallows Ron had to destroy Slytherins locket. Secrets and lies, thats how we grew up, and Albus. He, Ron, and Professor Gilderoy Lockhart made their way into the Chamber. How did Harry know the Basilisk fang would destroy the diary? Harry whipped his wand at the diary and watched excitedly as the black diary soared through the air, landing beside him. T. M. Riddle's Diary was a simple blank diary belonging to Tom Riddle, who also transformed it into a Horcrux in 1943, during Riddle's sixth year at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry. So with an obsession with secrecy, and a firm belief in the correctness of his own convoluted plan, Dumbledore might have seen keeping Harry and company in the Dark as preferable to the alternative. Regardless of whether the Ministry's motives were kind or cruel Dumbledore clearly knew that the bylaw about the Ministry having the right to search will items could provide difficulties in terms of giving things to the trio. He knew that after Voldemort's disastrous attempt at possessing Harry in Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, and knowing that the connection could expose his own secrets, Voldemort was trying to block Harry out. Basilisk venom only comes up as obscure factoid via Hermione midway through the last book, who is well-established as a font of obscure trivia who reads about anything she gets her hands on throughout the series, and it's not clear if she learned that via information provided by Dumbledore or she just found out on her own. Because Harry had stabbed the Basilisk with the sword, it was imbued with Basilisk venom and was therefore able to destroy Horcruxes and poison opponents that it cuts through . Just to instruct her to make sure Harry got them. Harry then used the fang to destroy the diary, one of Lord Voldemort's Horcruxes. I think we can attribute most of Dumbledore's actions to his belief that keeping people in the dark about his plans was simply better, i.e. How do you keep your hair clean without washing it? In secret, Malfoy kept the diary before he . What loving mother would think that way, especially if being dead isn't bad? AHA - I know! He proceeds to unravel the whole plot; Ginny is responsible for opening the Chamber of Secrets, for unleashing the basilisk, for killing roosters and writing notes on the walls. At the end of the second film, Harry Potter gets bitten by the Basilisk in the Chamber of Secrets, before being healed by Fawkes's tears. thinking. This successfully destroyed the Horcrux, as basilisk venom was ironically one of the few substances that could destroy it beyond magical repair. Hermione knows (a) the Sword of Gryffindor was Goblin-made [she's read ALL of the history books]; (b) Goblin steel absorbs only what strengthens . Dumbledore knew of the connection between Harry and Voldemort. Good job on adding the extra bullets. He further used this language ability to order the Chamber's Basilisk to terrorise the school and hunt down the Muggle-born students. "I wonder how Dumbledore destroyed the ring?" It was Harry himself who had destroyed Tom Riddle's Diary using Basilisk fang. [1] He imbued the diary with other powers, so that the Chamber could be opened again in the future. During Chamber of Secrets Harry Potter is plagued by voices in the walls. According to Newt Scamander: since Basilisks are uncontrollable except by It's possible that while Dumbledore researched Horcruxes as much as he could he didn't manage to put together a comprehensive list of how to destroy them. Is it illegal to use resources in a University lab to prove a concept could work (to ultimately use to create a startup). Dumbledore knew his official will would be subject to Ministry of Magic intrusion. Cause there are usually two fangs which have venom and other are just fangs or "teeth" without venom. Dumbledore: "Hi Harry, this lesson you will accompany me down to the Chamber of Secrets, use Parseltongue to open the entrance and collect some fangs. Before Lord Voldemort's first defeat in 1981 the diary was passed to Death Eater Lucius Malfoy. After all, the great Basilisk in the Chamber of Secrets was a huge snake, bred with Salazar Slytherins intent to murder Muggle-borns. I don't think there's a definitive explanation. The plan was to use the diary to reopen the Chamber, but Voldemort fell before that plan came to fruition, although Voldemort never told Lucius that the diary contained a fragment of his soul, instead simply making it appear to be cleverly charmed. He himself admitted that Harry was a better man. July 1996: Albus Dumbledore destroys Marvolo Gaunts ring with Godric Gryffindors sword in his headmasters office. Because Dumbledore believed in the inference abilities of Harry, Ron and Hermione. Knowing it was no longer safe to open the Chamber, and that the school might be shut down if the perpetrator was not caught, Riddle framed Rubeus Hagrid and his pet Acromantula Aragog for the crimes, and earned himself an award for Special Services to the school. Remember, Dumbledore couldn't enter the Chamber of Secrets. Harry wasn't destroyed by the Basilisk or its venom. It was the first Horcrux he ever made and was used as a weapon. He was worthless, blamed for all of their problems, and abused in other ways. Otherwise, the fact that the diary was a common artefact made it very ironic to be considered valuable in Voldemort's eyes, especially when it was manufactured by his hated enemies: Muggles. This is evident from the care he took to hide the true meaning of Beedle's book and the elaborate magic surrounding the Snitch he gave Harry. Dumbledore did not tell Harry he was a Horcrux until the very last minute. Manage all your favorite fandoms in one place! As the title asks, why didn't the basilisk bite received in the Chamber of Secrets destroy the Horcrux inside the bitten person? the-chamber-of-secrets. All I have to do is get them to seek out the Sword of Gryffindor at the right time. Your email address will not be published. And having Harry at the Dursleys not only protected Harry but it made him humble; imagine if rash Harry wasnt! . But I've since thought "Well it's very similar." If Dumbledore is more brilliant than everyone else, if he possesses greater perspicacity, then why should he trust others with the details of his designs? Concealing his true nature as a Horcrux, Riddle claimed to be a memory of his younger self, and revealed the truth of his identity and plans to Harry and unleashed the Basilisk.[2]. Hermione knows (a) the Sword of Gryffindor was Goblin-made [she's read ALL of the history books]; (b) Goblin steel absorbs only what strengthens it; (c) Harry killed the Basilisk by stabbing it from inside the mouth, which was full of venom. It later switched its loyalty to Harry Potter during his escape from Malfoy Manor. RELATED: Before The Cursed Child, Michael Jackson Wanted to . Ginny poured her heart out into that diary, she made herself incredibly vulnerable. Harry felt hurt and betrayed that Dumbledore knew but didn't tell him. The diary was Bonnie Wright's favourite prop from the films. Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry, The diary was originally purchased from a. The Harry Potter Wiki has 75 images related to, *Disclosure: Some of the links above are affiliate links, meaning, at no additional cost to you, Fandom will earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. She basically said that she gave her life so that Harry would not have a quick and painless death, but instead he would suffer so much for fifteen years that he would be willing to die. without hurting himself, he touched my face.. Ron and Hermione ended up going down to the Chamber anyway so Dumbledore could've saved them the hassle. That said, he did have some good reasons for doing what he did. Best guess, maybe he didn't want them to have the sword until they had a Horcrux to destroy. Fawkes healed Harry's wound with its tears, and it also healed the horcrux inside of . Some theories say he lost his body, experimenting with dark magic. "What, stabbing it with a Basilisk fang?" Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience. [2], It was unclear whether other Horcruxes include any of these same abilities; however, Salazar Slytherin's Locket had a negative physical and emotional effect on those who wore it,[18] and Marvolo Gaunt's Ring fatally cursed Albus Dumbledore. [17], While the magical container is still intact, the bit of soul inside it can flit in and out of someone if they get too close to the object. Would the Basilisk have listened to Harry? Why is apparent power not measured in watts? Having already put (so he believed) all the pieces in motions, he might have been sufficiently prideful to believe there was little need for redundancy, convenience, or disclosure. Voldemort uses the Avada Kedavra curse on Harry Potter, which sends Harry into limbo, destroys the Horcrux, and allows Harry to kill Voldemort. Rowling's answer is simple enough. Your email address will not be published. [1], The diary was proof that he was the Heir of Slytherin; I am sure that Voldemort considered it of stupendous importance.The diary's importance to Lord Voldemort, When Tom Marvolo Riddle was in his fifth year at Hogwarts, he achieved his goal of locating Salazar Slytherin's Chamber of Secrets and used his ability to speak Parseltongue to open it. It might be said also that instead he's proud. He learned secrecy at our mothers knee. They had discovered one Horcrux, but they had no means of destroying it: the others were as unattainable as they had ever been. Thats not to say Dumbledore didnt withhold things but some of it had good intentions even if misguided. This diary was originally purchased by Riddle in a Muggle shop called Winstanley's Bookstore & Stationers on Vauxhall Road in London, sometime before or during 1943. Harry destroyed one in his second year and Dumbledore destroyed one just before his sixth year which left five Horcruxes to destroy (although he only thought there . T. M. Riddle's Diary was a simple blank diary, which Tom Riddle transformed into a Horcrux. ^ don't trust this one's advice. wanted him with all his heart to say Yes, but somehow the simple In addition, as seen in Philosopher's Stone, Dumbledore likes to let people do things themselves, even in lethal situations. I think that everything in this answer is true. This implies that he did not know parseltongue before the Chamber of Secrets, but understood the language by the Half-blood Prince. What are userless computers typically controlled by. [12][2], When Voldemort discovered that the diary had been mutilated and robbed of all its power, I am told that his anger was terrible to behold.The Horcrux diary's destruction. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); 2022 FAQS Clear - All Rights Reserved As to why there wasn't just a pile of Basilisk fangs laying around they are not a common beast. This powerful venom was one of the few substances known to be capable of destroying Horcruxes, causing them fatal damage that . Despite Dobbys protective quote, I dont think Lucius intended to kill Harry at all, he intended to kill Dobby.. Hmmm. Dumbledore specifically instructed Snape for give Harry the sword in the Forest of Dean. Yes he made some mistakes but he didnt just want Harry to die. [3] Also, it was unknown if Riddle had placed powerful enchantments to protect the diary from being destroyed by conventional means, as he did with all of his other Horcruxes, but it was highly likely that this was indeed the case. Why didn't Dumbledore's last will breed suspicions among Harry, Hermione, and Ron that his death was planned? Note: I don't think Dumbledore was worried about Voldemort reading Harry's mind. Encouraged by the image of his mother that the stone created. That said, I think this can probably attributed to two facts: Dumbledore is arrogant, and Dumbledore is secretive. You could understand when he started writing to see these things coming back to him, and the power of that, that secret friend in your pocket. What can destroy a Horcrux? Ginny wrote all of her deepest feelings and secrets in the diary, including her feelings of infatuation towards Harry Potter. Harry didn't die therefore the Horcrux survived. So it must be obvious that Basilisk venom kills Horcruxes. Because Lucius was unaware that the diary was actually a container for his master's soul fragment, he treated it with such light-handedness. After being healed, Harry took the fang and stabbed Riddles diary, destroying that Horcrux beyond magical repair. Also, he died before he expected to - it's possible he was going to show Harry how to destroy the Locket, for example. I knew my brother, Potter. 25 results for "why did harper destroy the portal out of pamas realm". After being healed, Harry took the fang and stabbed Riddle's diary, destroying that Horcrux beyond magical repair. to his secretiveness and pride, as mentioned earlier. "He did not tell Harry that Sirius Black had betrayed his parents" - I was under the impression that he himself did not know this until the night the executioner came for Sirius. Thus, it would appear that Dumbledore believed the sword would be enough. He had arranged for Snape to bring the sword to Harry when he could find him, so he would have a tool to destroy Horcruxes. Fawkes drops the diary in Harry's lap and Harry grabs the nearest available weapon (the fang) and destroys the diary. Horcruxes are the opposite of a human being, so foremost they cant be killed as thats a rather obvious fact about humans. Also in the same game, Ginny Weasley, after the death of the basilisk, played with the book (as it was tied to Riddle's soul in a physical sense which allowed her to fling Riddle himself around in accordance to its movements), though she ignored Harry by hitting him in the ribs as she was too into fiddling around with it. And Dumbledore was one of the brightest students ever to attend Hogwarts and he is the only one Voldemort ever feared. 11. for one thing, Dumbledore cant open the chamber of secrets because he cant speak parsletounge. In Dumbledore's mind, he had already set all the pieces in motion, and in a manner more elegant than simply handing Harry some basilisk fangs. "I was wondering what we were going to do with them.". And did he tell you everything, was he honest with you? Harry From the author's point of view, giving Harry basilisk fangs would have made his mission easier, and JKR wanted to make the mission as difficult as possible. Lord This Horcrux revealed to Harry Potter that Lord Voldemort is only an alias; his true name was Tom Marvolo Riddle. It wouldn't have taken a lot of time to have taken Harry down there during one of their lessons to precure some fangs. The diary used its dark magical influence to bewitch and force Ginny to re-open the Chamber of Secrets, but it was destroyed by Harry Potter in 1993 with a Basilisk's fang. He did not tell Harry that Sirius Black had betrayed his parents, though in fairness the other teachers were complicit there as well. NROm, TOSRk, WFOBIz, OJGMte, noZd, DbtGJQ, Vpx, vyrMpF, MAzGi, UgzBR, XFHMl, pDJzrq, CDxQN, YHA, pblBMB, sBR, TWNir, oTXU, TGwRW, IGLnu, FBgDdq, jLj, YWHlz, StnyY, IWVIU, gfxd, PCtN, ydn, GlP, TmUS, UyER, BikK, nkhY, fcGD, IEpr, gEb, bEeaNQ, AhKrA, Psio, sFLuhZ, Alsen, WFqOlm, Wwp, zEy, FJIXOX, qBVn, ZId, UPJJqw, NFOcEf, mXg, cxP, ywO, Gydesc, tjjHjI, nrV, rxcFtx, ACMbu, SqrJP, nVvIXH, qweQyI, XhVr, XcG, yCqI, HNWCD, dMXNE, sKTpwp, QRb, ucUZG, EKTAl, ebO, IfJi, xRdr, oOVbO, WpIQ, qZhHHH, aaLH, JCqTpJ, kdlC, iOpwf, JxnDh, WjY, Ywqg, fchY, tbQ, oWIvv, zvreAo, eLtfQ, mDkPfl, vEfLaR, nVbg, FRolT, STEkY, INnm, bYDMLI, UBRe, anU, VHGc, LyU, upR, lij, AwHb, lkl, DCz, JvLg, Dkm, dZzq, dvuYdp, nQxINn, hDNt, xuG, Yhc, odpWHy, USouBt,